Orange Juice v Spandau Ballet

Illustration of a child dancing in a green jacket, red kilt, knee-high socks, and black shoes on a wooden floor.

On November 13th, 1980 Spandau Ballet made their Top of the Pops debut with their first single, To Cut a Long Story Short. Coiffed, primped and styled to within an inch of their lives, the north London quintet had kitted themselves out in full Highland dress for the occasion, complete with kilts, sashes, sporrans and ghillie brogues. Their singer, Tony Hadley clenched his fists, flicked his lacquered fringe, and sung a monotonous ditty about a non-existent soldier returning from a non-existent war. A few miles away in Barking, Essex, Billy Bragg saw their performance and felt galvanised—for entirely negative reasons—into becoming a musician himself. “Something inside of me snapped,” he later said, “I was waiting for a band to come along and play the kind of music I wanted to hear [but instead] I saw Spandau Ballet wearing kilts. At that moment I finally realised it was gonna have to be me.”

Black-and-white photo of Martin Kemp playing bass guitar while wearing a tartan kilt onstage.
Martin Kemp performing “To Cut a Long Story Short” ©Brian Cooke / Redferns

Why did the appearance of Spandau Ballet mark this turning point for Bragg? Was it the band’s relentless seriousness, the bland thudding of their debut single, their appropriation of Highland dress as narcissistic performance in a manner not seen in Britain since the age of George IV? Or perhaps it was the way in which all of these things seemed to be somehow wrapped up in the politics of Spandau Ballet? That November, Britain felt like a struggling, divided nation, but just a few weeks earlier, in the pages of Sounds, Spandau Ballet had published an upbeat “manifesto for the eighties” in which they’d celebrated their explicit championing of dandy style over substance (“the people who come to see us are interested in two things: enjoying themselves and looking good”), allied themselves with the entrepreneurial values championed by Britain’s new prime minister, Margaret Thatcher (“it’s about ambition. The whole scene attracts people who want to achieve something, whether it’s art or whether it’s money”) and, in the same year that multi-racial 2-tone bands had begun to dominate the UK singles charts, had described the widely-perceived whiteness of their music as “a question of identifying yourself more with music from your culture rather than somebody else’s”. Riots had recently erupted in the Bristol community of St Pauls in response to rising youth unemployment and the police’s heavy-handed implementation of the “sus” laws, but Spandau Ballet felt that British kids should be out buying their records alongside designer clothes in the style that was now dubbed “New Romantic”. “But what about kids who are unemployed,” enquired Sounds’ journalist Betty Page “who don’t have the money to buy clothes like that?” Decrying the “pack instincts” of the “grey anonymous mass” and their predictable fondness for “polytechnic rock” Gary Kemp brushed off the question “what I’d really like is, instead of kids wearing scruffy, terrible clothes … it’d be much better if they were doing the opposite of that, wanting to look good. The kind of people that come and see us would just rather spend a lot of money on clothes,” he concluded, “than libraries full of Jean Cocteau.” There were just too many bands about at the moment, Kemp went on, without any style at all, “bands like Orange Juice,” he noted dismissively, who were now “making music for over 21s.”

Edwyn Collins singing into a microphone while playing guitar on a dark stage
Edwyn Collins performing with Orange Juice at Paisley’s Bungalow Bar. ©Martin McClenaghan

In the autumn months of, 1980, Orange Juice and Spandau Ballet were both new British bands with an up-tempo pop-py feel that sounded comparably fresh and forward-looking. Around both bands there circulated a lot of positive noise, and the word was that both might be about to make it big. Yet by taking a pot-shot at their rivals’ sound and dress-down style Gary Kemp had highlighted the material gulf that separated the two. Having come up through London’s West-End Blitz club, where aristos and couturiers cavorted in wigs and crinolines beneath photographs of Winston Churchill, Spandau Ballet had just signed to Chrysalis in an unprecedented deal that was the most valuable for a previously unsigned artist in the UK at that time. Orange Juice, on the other hand, were signed to Glasgow’s fledging post-punk indie label, Postcard Records, underwritten by a mixture of their own savings and borrowed friends-and-family funds. While Spandau Ballet received a “superstar” royalty rate on their retail record sales, Orange Juice had gleaned little income from the two singles they’d so far released, which had been pressed in small runs, with cheap black-and-white printed sleeves, jazzed up during parties of felt-tip colouring-in, before being hawked to record shops, distributors, journalists and DJs personally by members of the band.

Black-and-white photo of Strawberry Switchblade  in polka-dot outfits sitting indoors, surrounded by furniture and records.
Postcard pals, Strawberry Switchblade, helped decorate Orange Juice’s record sleeves

Spandau Ballet not only had big-label financial backing but were surrounded by a moneyed entourage of fashion designers, stylists, hairdressers and oily PR guru, Robert Elms, who had given the band their deeply dubious name (they were previously called “Gentry”), introduced them with appalling “poetry” at carefully choreographed secret gigs, and assiduously framed them to the press as the vanguard of the aspirational youth culture he envisioned for the 1980s. In Glasgow, meanwhile, Orange Juice were supported by a small, keen group of local fans, and their manager, the erratic, truculent, and unreliable Alan Horne, who ran Postcard Records from the wardrobe of the flat he shared with their bassist, David McClymont at 185, West Princes Street. And while Spandau Ballet had received a £200,000 advance for their debut album, Orange Juice had so far reaped little financial reward from their fledgling musical “career,” and were (like many young musicians in the 1980s) supplementing their income by signing on. But pointing out this last fact in a swiftly-penned repost (band-rivalry back and forth then being the meat and drink of the popular music press) was to backfire on Orange Juice’s singer, Edwyn Collins, when he found a stern letter from the DHSS dropping through his letterbox, followed by the cessation of his giro.

Black-and-white portrait of Orange Juice with a large flower in the foreground.
Orange Juice

Orange Juice and Spandau Ballet have always, for me, represented the opposing poles of everything I love and loathe about early 1980s pop. Preparing to write this piece has prompted me to reflect on why that might be so. Why, exactly, am I so strongly in camp OJ? I can perhaps make the argument with a quick comparison of two tracks which both bands were playing in 1981: Muscle Bound (the third single from Spandau Ballet’s debut album, Journeys to Glory) and Consolation Prize, a jangly staple of the gigs Orange Juice played in Paisley’s bungalow bar.

In the extraordinary video which cost twice its original budget, and accompanied Muscle Bound’s release, the members of Spandau Ballet are swathed in pseudo-imperialist Peter O’Toole costumes while struggling on horseback through Cumbrian snowdrifts, wielding scythes and burning torches. A group of dwarves in blackface flee from the band’s oncoming advances, before Tony Hadley appears with his conquering hero anthem “tough is the leather that’s strapped to my skin,” he intones with thrust-out chin, “strong are the bonds that we sing.” The video is completely ludicrous by today’s (or any) standards, but, like everything Spandau Ballet did, it also somehow manages to take itself very, very seriously, disturbing crusades-meets-strength-through-joy aesthetic and all. “Try playing Muscle Bound, back-to-back with Tomorrow Belongs to Me from the soundtrack of Bob Fosse’s Cabaret,” Sunie Fletcher advised after the single’s release in Record Mirror, “the mood is the same. Tread very carefully for all our sakes.” Nor were the band’s earnest celebrations of masculine muscle lost on Britain’s far right when, in the 25th issue of British Bulldog, (the youth magazine of the 1980s National Front), Eddie Morrison praised the “strains of classical and traditional Aryan music,” he felt he could detect in Spandau Ballet.

Alongside po-faced, proto-fascist Muscle Bound let’s consider the playful ambiguities of Orange Juice’s Consolation Prize, in which Edwyn Collins proposes himself as the prize of the song’s title to a girl whose boyfriend, he observes, appears to be treating her very badly. While the boyfriend only seems to make her cry, Collins is able to cheer her up with his “frightfully camp” “fringe like Roger McGuinn,” and is beginning to win her round with laughter.  On stage in pubs and clubs around Glasgow, Collins was notorious for hamming up his own effeminacy in response to belligerent punk hecklers “imitating an especially camp style to annoy them even more” as Dave McCullough put it in the NME. With a joyous swirl of guitar underlain by a Scottish-accordion-sounding synth, Collins celebrates his refusal to conform to alpha-male stereotypes alongside the mischief and irony of his own defiant selfhood: “I’ll never be man enough for you,” he happily sings, “I’ll never be man enough for you.” In Consolation Prize, the whirling reels of a community ceilidh are replayed as post-punk identity anthem, as Collins lauds the virtues of not getting the girl, while remaining completely himself.

I could continue to compare the bloodless “soul” of  Spandau Ballet’s Chant no. 1 with the sweet bubblegum groove of Orange Juice’s Rip it Up and Start Again; I might set Spandau Ballet’s increasingly slick, calculated, corporate style against Orange Juice’s ramshackle DIY aesthetic; I could talk about how Orange Juice were playing miners’ benefit gigs while Spandau Ballet sang their sub Bond-theme mega-hit, Gold, to a Wembley arena full of 1980s London bankers, but ultimately I think the issue of allegiance to team OJ or team SB might just come down to the question of whether or not you have a sense of humour.

Vintage illustration of a Scottish  Highlander in a tartan kilt holding a cane, and part of another kilted figure.

After Spandau Ballet’s tartan-clad appearance on Top of the Pops, it appears that Orange Juice might have been galvanised into action just as much as Billy Bragg, for it was at precisely this moment that the band’s manager, Alan Horne, decided to change the label’s aesthetic, branding, and identity with a flourish which quickly became Postcard’s recognisable calling card. Christening the label, “the sound of young Scotland” (in a knowing and sardonic nod to Motown), Horne proceeded to both subvert and reclaim the very images of Scottish heritage which their London rivals had appropriated so very heavy-handedly.

Black-and-white street market in a narrow brick alley, with vendors, shoppers, and tables of secondhand goods.
Paddys Market in Glasgow ©Martin McClenaghan

Combining paper ephemera (which Horne and Edwyn Collins had picked up at Glasgow’s Paddy’s market) with a heavy dose of post-punk irony, graphic designer, Krysia Klasicki created a collage of old-fashioned scraps, in which tartan clad figures performed “traditional” Scottish Highland activities, like shooting, curling, and striding through the heather. By ripping up and reworking Spandau Ballet’s hackneyed, shortbread-tin-Scotland image; by dressing as makeshift, post-punk things of shreds and patches rather than preened and primped New Romantic dandies; with falling-and-laughing self-deprecation in place of their rivals’ pompous self-inflation, unlike Spandau Ballet, Orange Juice always managed to take the piss out of themselves whilst simultaneously reminding you exactly where they were coming from.

Vintage Postcard Records of Scotland record sleeve featuring illustrated Scottish figures and a curler

Kate Davies


In preparing to write this piece, I traced the Spandau Ballet / Orange Juice rivalry of 1980-81 and reviews of the early releases of both bands through the pages of Sounds, NME, Record Mirror and Creem all available via Rocks Back Pages (https://www.rocksbackpages.com/)

See also:

Chris Brickley and Martin McClenaghan, Glasgow: Post-Punk City (2023)

Simon Goddard, Simply Thrilled: The Preposterous Story of Postcard Records (2014)

Simon Reynolds Rip it Up and Start Again: Post-Punk 1978-1984 (2005)

Matthew Worley and Nigel Copsey, ‘White Youth: The Far Right, Punk, and British Youth Culture 1977-1987” JOMEC 9 (2016)

The Glasgow School: An Oral History of Postcard Records (documentary) (2023)


Discover more from Kate Davies

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Comments

35 responses to “Orange Juice v Spandau Ballet”

  1. I love this so much – thank you for writing it. I missed the politics of Spandau Ballet – I never understood their weird name and was only dimly aware of “Gold” because someone put it on a mixtape for me. It’s fascinating to read more about them – the construction of their image, and their wholehearted embrace of the individualistic, aspirational politics of the 1980s. I also had not heard of Orange Juice until reading this! It’s so great to learn more about these bands and to think about them in the context of 1980s Thatcher’s Britain.

    I came of age in John Major’s era and the introduction of the criminal justice bill under his government, which went into effect when I was about fifteen years old and beginning to participate in a glorious range of anti-establishment activities. My heart was completely stolen by the sharp-edged dance music that erupted in response – in opposition – to the criminal justice bill. I will always adore the angry, anarchic early rave music that defined free and unofficial musical gatherings and the protest movements of that time.

    Thinking about Spandau Ballet and their relationship to Thatcherism, it strikes me that something similar happened a bit later, when Tony Blair’s new labour government courted Britpop as a means of making their manifesto accessible to the youth. I lacked the language at the time to unpack it, but it made me deeply uneasy. It strikes me now that the Blair government appropriated the coolness and creativity of Britpop to signal relevance and approachability, while quietly continuing to further the rampant neoliberal capitalist agenda started by Thatcher. Jarvis Cocker got it, I reckon.

    Thanks for a thought-provoking read and for all the lovely historic details here – the felt-tip pen records; the collaged ephemera; the contrasting schools of masculinity – the comparison of that scene from Cabaret with Spandau Ballet’s horrendous and unironic Musclebound – YE GODS.

    1. Mark Fisher wrote brilliantly about Blair’s Britpop flirtations as being “like a double death: the end of history laughing at us, the corpse of white lad rock summoned to serenade socialism succumbing to capitalist realism”

      1. Thank you for the steer – I must read Capitalist Realism; that is such a perfect encapsulation.

  2. Great read. I’m totally team OJ

  3. luca zani Avatar

    Hi,

    I’m Luca, editor of Critick, an arts and culture magazine of essays and reviews on Substack. I’ve been reading your stuff, and really enjoyed your work.

    We’re open to submissions and I’d love to have you contribute. That could be a guest essay, a review, or something you’ve already been working on. Pitches are welcome too, and there’s no rigid format or length.

    You can find the submit details in the Critick bio (critickmag.com / critick.substack.com). If you have an idea, feel free to just reply here and we can talk it through.

    Thanks for reading, and I hope to hear from you.

    Luca

  4. Recollections of 80s music may vary!

  5. Thanks Kate for taking me down memory lane! (speaking as a Glaswegian, late teen/early 20s fan of OJ in 1980s). I was accordingly intrigued by the title of this year’s club given your interest in jazz and I loved this delve into the musical politics of the day (although also loved the essay on Herbie Hancock). OJ and Postcard’s legacy have undoubtedly contributed to a thriving DIY music scene in Glasgow that campaigns for access to music opportunities for all particularly for women. Have you seen the ‘Since Yesterday’ film? Strawberry Switchblade feature and it develops some of the arguments about music that you make in your essay but with the emphasis on women. Looking forward to next week’s essay!

  6. So sad you never lived as an adult during thus era of emerging music in this country and the island of Great Britain as we were called then.
    There is good and bad everywhere and many of us have deep and long ancestral routes to Scotland but prefer other places. I have the right to my wear my family tartan if I chose.
    Music is governed by money men always has and always will be as is the film industry. Do you curse Gerard Butler a firm Glaswegian for his money making films set all over the globe.
    Let creatives be creatives whether in Craft Art Music or Films they all have steps up enroute before being popular.

    1. I honestly have no idea what your point is…. have I somehow hit a nerve?

      1. Full of harsh criticism of an era you do not know
        Anyone can wear kilts
        Not everyone in Scotland now has ancestry there at all

        1. I fear you may be missing my key points about post-punk irony / possessing a sense of humour…

  7. Ann Sutton Avatar
    Ann Sutton

    Spandau Ballet are still chasing the “celebrity culture”. I’m Irish and and I find any cultural appropriation really irritating. Maybe I am easily irritated!

  8. Lucie Rixon Avatar
    Lucie Rixon

    This is wonderful!! Thank you for validating my childhood impression of the Spands as the dead-eyed Tories of Pop. 😁.

    My best friend at primary school thought that they were the best thing ever, and forced me to listen to Through the Barricades whenever I went to her house. I seem to remember retaliating with World Shut Your Mouth by Julian Cope…

  9. And as for the Muscle Bound video, oh my goodness. I lied – the side of power in the US has Kid Rock, and transplanted to a different context he’d be playing this stuff. gross. (Also after listening to the OJ tracks, this song is so musically lifeless!)

  10. I love a good David vs Goliath story in a totally specific context. My own musical experience growing up was about five times removed from this (different decade, continent, culture, religion, parents weirdly strict about music), but this essay made me feel as if I was there. It seems like there were two sides to the musical culture war going on in the UK back then, whereas these days in the US, art seems to be all on one side and power all on the other.

  11. Rhona Arthur Avatar
    Rhona Arthur

    Kate, that’s absolutely fascinating and not something I’d picked up on at all. I wasn’t ever in either camp at the time, so I’ll have to do a bit of listening and reflecting. Music, like books, has always been political. Wealth and class drove the creation of a lot of it, while communities created their own grassroots traditions. I don’t think I’d ever thought of the political upheaval and change of the 1980s and the popular music like that, although the protest music of the 1960s and 70s is so well known and understood.

    Thanks for giving me something to ponder over this afternoon.
    Rhona

    1. Thanks, Rhona, I couldn’t have put it better myself. Definitely time for some reflection. I thought i was politically aware at the time, but obviously not!

  12. Such a brilliant and thoughtful post Kate. I salute you :)

  13. patricia McGuire Avatar
    patricia McGuire

    I still have my orange juice 45s the glorious results of a miss spent youth.
    Thank you
    Tricia in the US

  14. The Other Kristen Avatar
    The Other Kristen

    Fascinating, Kate; thank you. As an American who’s a little bit older than you, pretty much all I knew of Spandau Ballet was “True.” I’d never heard of Orange Juice. I am so glad to better understand the cultural context in which these bands arose, and that was completely invisible to me as a young person in the US at the time.

  15. Islington was not always affluent and in 1980 had plenty of grim tenement housing where families lived in very cramped conditions. Children often left school early. Young people aspired to having more than their parents who had lived through WW2. Clothing, sharp haircuts and designer labels were a way to express this. Looking good and dressing well was always very much part of working class culture in North and East London.

  16. Lin James Avatar

    Fantastic! I remember Spandau Ballet doing a photoshoot outside my workplace in the moody backstreets of Clerkenwell just before they became huge and were just kids from the local estate with their eyes on the bright lights. The name was always horrific, but they weren’t the only ones – March Violets, A Certain Ratio, New Order …

    1. Yes, there was a lot of it about…

  17. Debbie Barnett Avatar
    Debbie Barnett

    My mother occasionally to say (somewhat disparagingly) of objects she thought weren’t quite the thing: Where did you get that? Paddy’s market?

    She was born in Belfast in the ’20s.

    1. I’m from NI too and we still use the term Paddy’s market, I honestly thought it was Irish as well … maybe there was more than one Paddy ! :)

      1. My mother, a Northumbrian used the phrase Paddy’s Market about my bedroom as a child! Apparently there was a market in Newcastle known as Paddys Market in Victorian times, now Bigg Market I think.

  18. I am 73 and didn’t like New Romantic much.. I was more a folky girl, plus protest songs etc (and rock n roll) and haven’t heard of Orange Juice but I sure love your article..
    Brilliant and educational!

  19. Thanks for this piece. I found it very interesting and it made me rethink the music of the eighties. I loved the seventies, especially soul and Motown and was dismayed by the emergence of punk and then New Romantic.
    My dad worked at a coal pit and suffered under the Thatcher Years. At the time I didn’t equate politics with music – until I heard U2. I loved the perspective in your article and that it offered an opportunity to reflect on those years through a different lens.

    1. my dad also worked in industry, and was made redundant in the early ’80s. A difficult time for us non-new romantics!

  20. Jill Bevis Avatar
    Jill Bevis

    A wonderful piece of writing to enjoy on a Sunday morning, thank you Kate. Once everyone is up I’ll play some OJ tracks & then reread your post.

  21. kaatje1959 Avatar
    kaatje1959

    Hi Kate,

    Wjhat makes you think that people want to read this? I don’t.

    1. No one’s forcing you…

    2. Goodness, kaatje1959, the internet will be absolutely exhausting for you if you feel the need to comment on everything you’re not interested in. With respect, perhaps decide it’s not for you and move on. It will save you so much time.

    3. I do. Do I “win”?

      1. I do too, I guess we all win!
        Still have my 7″ copy of Rip It Up and I remember seeing them on Whistle Test, seems like aeons ago…
        I am sadly old enough to have grown of age with punk in the late 70s and remember the utter contempt for the likes of SB, all style and no substance, never mind the politics.

        And can I add a shout out for Edwyn Collins’ Girl Like You, one of the best songs ever…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *